Wednesday, October 3, 2012

Product Review, Tattler Lids

While canning chili beans this week I used some Tattler Lids for the first time.  I read the directions several times to make sure I did everything correctly.   Of the 12 one did not seal because of obvious user error and 2 others did not seal, reason unknown.  I also used 9 standard lids and 1 did not seal so the sealing rate is about the same.  The recipe used had tomatoes and tomato juice in it and the lids are stained now because of the tomatoes.  You know how if you put tomato based items in a plastic bowl and it will stain the plastic.  I use bleach in my water to wash my canning items and it did not remove the stains.  I also tried using a scrubby with baking soda with no luck.  The 9 jars that did seal are going to have the same problem.  The lids like I said earlier were stained from the canning so I soaked the 3 that did not seal overnight in a little water, bleach and soap.
I reprocessed the chili beans this morning and when they were cool I removed the rings and noticed that the lids are coming apart, pealing.  They are now two colors of white and you can see where the rings were and it won't wash off.   I contacted Tattler and they said "It appears the lids have been damaged by the bleach in your attempt to remove the stains.  Bleach is a strong oxidizing agent which is incompatible with the plastic used in Tattler lids.  The same is true for strong acids such as hydrochloric acid and both are not recommended for use in conjunction with this type of plastic."   I so wanted this to turn out better so I could find an alternative to buying the metal lids constantly but at this time I will not be purchasing this product.  
Everyone's experience is different and this was mine.  If you do purchase these or own them don't use bleach to wash them.  If you put them in a dishwasher you should check to make sure there isn't bleach in it.


Jar on left was done yesterday, the jar on the right was done today.  The lid used on the right was one I soaked in water, bleach and soap to remove the stains from the tomatoes.  If you look closely you can see the plastic on the lid is pealing.

I received this product free for the purpose of reviewing it and no other compensation was received for this review. The opinions expressed in this review are my honest opinions.

5 comments:

  1. Wow, I have some tattlers but haven't used them yet with tomato products. Good to know about the bleach. I don't remember seeing anything about that in the instructions. Is it in there?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've read everything they have published on their site and the info that came with the lids and no where did I see anything about not using bleach. In one of my first emails to them about the stains THEY suggested I run them through the dishwasher and most dishwasher products contain bleach. Oh well sure glad I didn't spend any money getting some.

      Delete
  2. I just found your site and LOVE all that you've canned. I recently began to can meat: chicken and hamburger. I wonder how you canned your bacon. Did you cook it up first? Cover it with water? Can you give me some details? Thanks!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. http://paulaoretirement.blogspot.com/2012/07/stevia-and-canned-bacon.html


      If you follow the link above it has step by step pictures and directions. This was the first time I canned it and then I canned more in September. We have had the canned bacon now several times and we just love it. My grandson Brandon always wants it when he comes over.

      Delete
  3. I was wondering if it would be possible to use Tattler's rubber rings with old metal lids since the reason we do not want to reuse the metal lids is because of the rubber on it being a "one" time only thing. At least that is what I have always thought, but then again, I don't can stuff.

    ReplyDelete